Skip to content
Buffetter Research
Go back

Quantitative Critique: 🏰 7 Powers Screen + Overreaction Kelly (34-Quarter Walk-Forward Backtest)

1. Executive Verdict: Did the 4-Stage Funnel Beat the Market on Skill or Luck?

Across the 34-quarter out-of-sample walk-forward simulation (2017–2025) with Marcos López de Prado target-label purging (63d embargo) and 15 bps round-trip transaction friction across the 137-asset multi-sector & 3-tier historic IPO universe, the 🏰 7 Powers Screen + Overreaction Kelly (4-Stage Funnel) delivered +324.72% cumulative return (+18.55% CAGR) versus +154.99% (+11.66% CAGR) for the SPY S&P 500 benchmark.

Important

Key Quantitative Takeaway: Approximately 75% of the outperformance (+522 bps/yr over SPY) comes from Stage 0 & Stage 1 Left-Tail Elimination (filtering out unseasoned IPO hype and structural moat erosion), while 25% (+167 bps/yr) comes from Stage 2 & Stage 3 Overreaction Quarter-Kelly Sizing. The strategy wins not by chasing high-beta moonshots, but by refusing to own decaying franchises during tightening regimes (-0.68% in 2022 vs. -14.09% SPY and -31.04% Rejected Moat Traps).

Strategy Cohort Total Return CAGR Sharpe Sortino Max Drawdown Win Rate vs SPY Jensen’s Alpha
🏰 7 Powers + Overreaction Kelly (Stage 0–3) +324.72% +18.55% 0.85 1.40 -22.72% 61.8% +6.72%/yr
🛡️ 7 Powers + 3M T-Bill Barbell +265.49% +16.47% 0.87 1.43 -18.93% 58.8% +6.03%/yr
🏰 Stage 1 Equal-Weight (Moat Screen Only) +276.38% +16.88% 0.86 1.38 -15.78% 58.8% +5.22%/yr
🤖 Quant ML Top Quintile (Q5 Unscreened) +225.79% +14.93% 0.58 1.24 -40.87% 55.9% +3.27%/yr
📈 S&P 500 Benchmark (SPY) +154.99% +11.66% 0.53 0.78 -21.11% — 0.00%
⚠️ Rejected Fallen Angels & Broken IPOs +131.03% +10.35% 0.25 0.52 -51.61% 44.1% -8.68%/yr
📉 Quant ML Bottom Quintile (Q1) -7.08% -0.86% -0.19 -0.26 -61.81% 32.4% -12.52%/yr

2. Attribution Decomposition: What Genuinely Worked vs. Noise

A. Stage 0 & Stage 1 Moat Screening (+522 bps/yr Structural Alpha)

  • Funnel Compression: At an average quarterly rebalance date, 101 active tickers enter Stage 0, 90 survive the IPO lock-up seasoning filter (>= 378 calendar days post-IPO and drawdown > -40% from post-IPO ATH), 31 pass the point-in-time cross-sectional 7 Powers threshold (M >= 62 with non-collapsing 126d moat trajectory >= -8), and 12 receive active Quarter-Kelly capital allocation.
  • Fallen-Angel Ejection (-8.68%/yr Jensen’s Alpha Avoided): Dynamically ejecting decaying incumbents and broken growth stories—such as INTC (M=26.9), BA (M=28.9), DIS (M=26.9), BABA (M=27.9), DOCU (M=26.8), KSS (M=25.9), SPCE (M=26.8), and BYND (M=28.8)—compressed Maximum Drawdown from -40.87% (unscreened ML Q5) down to -15.78% (Stage 1 Equal-Weight) and -18.93% (Barbell).

B. Stage 2 & Stage 3 Overreaction Kelly Sizing (+167 bps/yr Incremental Alpha)

  • Comparing 7 Powers + Overreaction Kelly (+18.55% CAGR, -22.72% MDD) against Stage 1 Equal-Weight (+16.88% CAGR, -15.78% MDD) reveals the exact trade-off of active conviction sizing: concentrating up to 12% per position into oversold wide-moat pullbacks adds +167 bps/yr of annualized return (+48.3% cumulative wealth over 8.5 years) at the cost of +6.94% deeper maximum drawdown.
  • Meanwhile, the 3M T-Bill Hurdle Barbell (+16.47% CAGR, 0.87 Sharpe, 1.43 Sortino) achieves the highest risk-adjusted efficiency in the entire study by parking unallocated capital in risk-free Treasury bills (macro_yield_3m) whenever high-moat equities become overbought (RSI_14 >= 75).

C. 34-Quarter Factor Attribution by Dominant Helmer Power

Decomposing every Stage 1 survivor by its highest point-in-time normalized pillar confirms which structural moats actually compound:

Dominant Helmer Power Pillar Avg Quarterly Picks Annualized CAGR Avg Quarterly Return Hit Rate (>0%) Max Drawdown
⚙️ Process Power & Scale Economies (NVDA, LLY, TSM, CAT, COST) 8.3 +20.00% +5.33% 67.6% -22.27%
🔒 Switching Costs (MSFT, ORCL, NOW, CRM, ISRG) 6.8 +12.91% +3.77% 67.6% -15.88%
💎 Cornered Resource & Branding (AAPL, UNH, REGN, NVO) 6.4 +10.01% +2.74% 70.6% -12.20%
🌐 Network Economies & Counter-Positioning (META, GOOGL, NFLX, UBER) 9.5 +9.33% +3.18% 61.8% -34.10%

3. Regime Diagnosis: Why the Model Trailed in 2018, 2019, and 2021

Year 🏰 7 Powers Kelly 🛡️ 7 Powers Barbell 🏰 Stage 1 Equal-Wt 🤖 Quant ML Q5 📈 SPY Benchmark ⚠️ Rejected Traps
2017 (3Q) +19.33% +13.73% +13.76% +12.71% +9.97% +8.47%
2018 -11.33% -9.71% -9.00% -15.30% -5.82% -12.66%
2019 +19.16% +18.43% +22.41% +19.83% +27.79% +19.65%
2020 +47.20% +41.15% +26.40% +69.64% +16.17% +54.78%
2021 +5.47% +7.26% +23.81% +11.67% +18.51% +16.13%
2022 -0.68% -0.28% -5.81% -22.61% -14.09% -31.04%
2023 +24.80% +23.22% +25.72% +34.50% +21.11% +35.09%
2024 +39.04% +35.42% +24.47% +35.58% +20.06% +19.01%
2025 (3Q) +27.84% +23.09% +37.98% +23.62% +13.38% +29.38%
  • The 2021 Euphoria Penalty (+5.47% Kelly vs. +23.81% Stage 1 Equal-Weight): In low-volatility stimulus melt-ups (2021), Stage 1 selected the right compounders (+23.81%), but Stage 2’s 0.35x overbought penalty (RSI_14 >= 75) prematurely cut winners while Stage 3 reallocated into value laggards experiencing temporary pullbacks (RSI_14 < 45).
  • The 2022 Tightening Triumph (-0.68% Kelly vs. -14.09% SPY & -31.04% Traps): When the Federal Reserve hiked rates aggressively in 2022, Stage 0/1 ejected unprofitable tech and broken IPOs while Stage 3 demanded a rising 3M T-Bill hurdle (macro_yield_3m), preserving nearly 100% of capital.

4. The Hard Audit: 5 Methodological & Structural Vulnerabilities

Despite eliminating manual ticker selection and De Prado target leakage, five structural flaws remain in the v1 implementation:

  1. Price/Volume Proxies Masquerading as Accounting Moats: Because historical point-in-time SEC XBRL statements (Gross Margin, ROIC, R&D/Rev, Deferred Revenue) are not stored in the 12-year daily parquet panel, the 7 Powers scores are approximated from price/volume behavior (ret_252d, dist_sma_200, vol_63d, cmf_20, obv_slope_20). During commodity spikes (e.g., NEM in 2020 or OXY/SLB in 2022), cyclical price momentum can temporarily mimic Process Power and Scale Economies.
  2. Static is_whale_holding Broadcast Leakage: In src/historical_dataset.py, is_whale_holding and whale_manager_count are populated from data/whales.yaml and broadcast across a ticker’s historical rows (weight 0.25 in the Cornered Resource pillar). While modest (~3.75% of total M_i,t), historical backtests should either use point-in-time SEC 13F-HR filing dates or zero out static whale flags.
  3. Quarterly (63-Day) Rebalance vs. 14-Day Overreaction Horizon Mismatch: RSI_14 < 45 and bb_pct_b < 0.25 capture 5-to-15 trading day liquidity shocks, whereas the walk-forward engine only rebalances once every 63 trading days. Mean-reversion velocity decays substantially after day 25.
  4. Unenforced Intra-Quarter 2x ATR Stop-Loss: Stage 3 sizes positions using an asymmetric payoff ratio b_i,t assuming downside is capped at max(2 * ATR_14, 5%), yet the quarterly simulation evaluates raw target_return_3m at day 63 without triggering an intra-quarter exit when target_max_drawdown_3m breaches -2 * ATR_14.
  5. Delisted Bankruptcy Censorship in Yahoo Finance: While our 137-ticker universe includes surviving busts (SPCE, BYND, PTON, LCID, RIVN, WBA, INTC), completely delisted liquidations (SIVB, FRC, BBBY, WE) are absent from Yahoo Finance’s active feed—meaning the Rejected Fallen Angels cohort (+10.35% CAGR, -51.61% MDD) still slightly overstates the return of buying moat traps.

5. Phase 2 Engineering Roadmap

  • Fix 1 (Zero Static Whale Leakage): Strip is_whale_holding and whale_manager_count from historical backtest moat scoring in src/ml_backtest.py until point-in-time EDGAR 13F-HR timestamps are ingested.
  • Fix 2 (Enforce Intra-Quarter 2x ATR Stop-Outs): Cap quarterly realized losses in src/ml_backtest.py at -2 * ATR_14 - 15 bps slippage whenever target_max_drawdown_3m breaches the stop level, aligning realized execution with the Quarter-Kelly denominator.
  • Fix 3 (21-Day Tactical Overreaction Rebalance Within 63-Day Moat Refresh): Recompute the slow-moving Stage 1 7 Powers universe quarterly (63d), but execute Stage 2/3 overreaction entries and euphoria trims monthly (21d) to match the half-life of short-term RSI_14 dislocations.


Previous Post
Market Memo: Top Ideas & Bet Sizing (10 Nov 06:38 UTC)
Next Post
Market Memo: Top Ideas & Bet Sizing (10 Nov 08:37 UTC)